Advice From Craig
Selling a property at a loss can feel like admitting defeat. But if that property is costing you money every month, selling could be the decision that puts you in a better financial position.
The question is simple: What will it cost you to sell today, compared with what it could cost you to keep holding?
Yesterday on our weekly listing strategy call, an agent on my team walked us through a condo she’s been trying to sell.
The seller bought it a few years ago, and the HOA dues keep climbing. Even with a tenant, the rent doesn’t cover the mortgage and HOA, so he’s writing a check every month. When it’s vacant, that check gets much bigger. They’ve already reduced the price twice, and showings are still thin.
Another agent jumped in with almost the same story. His seller had just realized he would probably need to bring money to closing.
His first reaction was, “That’s brutal.”
His next sentence was, “Well, I’m paying a lot every month on this thing.”
That’s the moment I want to talk about. A lot of owners get stuck there, and the way you frame the decision can change how you see your options.
Waiting Has a Cost
For years, the default advice from many real estate investors, myself included, was to hold on. The market would recover. Rates would come down. Be patient.
I’ve had to reconsider how broadly I give that advice.
Holding can make sense when the property is financially sustainable and you have a clear reason to keep it. But when you’re covering a shortfall every month, “just wait” comes with a price.
Maybe the market improves enough to make holding worthwhile. Maybe it stays flat. Maybe rising HOA dues or an unexpected repair make the numbers worse.
You don’t need to predict the future perfectly. You do need to understand what waiting costs and what would have to happen for it to pay off.
What Would You Pay to Stop Losing Money?
People hate the idea of paying money to sell something. You bought a property hoping it would build wealth, and now you might have to write a check to get out of it.
So look at the decision from another angle.
Suppose:
- Your property has a monthly cash shortfall of $1,000 after rent and expenses.
- Selling today would require you to bring $36,000 to closing.
Would you pay $36,000 once to eliminate a $1,000 monthly obligation?
That would improve your cash flow by $12,000 a year. Your upfront payment would equal three years of those savings.
The annual cash savings are about 33% of the cash needed to exit. That isn’t the same as earning a 33% investment return, because selling also means giving up future appreciation, mortgage principal paydown, and any other benefits of ownership. But it’s a useful way to put the cost of selling into perspective.
Also, bringing $36,000 to closing is different from receiving $36,000 less than you hoped. One requires additional cash. The other reflects a lower sale outcome than your target. Your decision should use the actual proceeds and costs, rather than the number you originally wanted.
Vacancy Makes Waiting More Expensive
A property that costs you $1,000 a month with a tenant might cost $2,500 a month when it’s empty.
At that point, every additional month on the market takes another bite out of your eventual proceeds.
For example, holding out three more months for an extra $5,000 in sale price wouldn’t improve your position if carrying the vacant property costs $7,500 during that time.
A price reduction that feels painful today can sometimes be the less expensive path.
Compare Selling With a Realistic Holding Plan
The mistake I see most often is comparing a sale at today’s price with the hope that everything improves next spring.
Instead, compare selling today with a specific holding plan.
Sell Now
Selling establishes your exit cost and ends your future carrying obligations once the transaction closes. It can also free up time, reduce stress, and potentially improve your ability to pursue another investment.
The tradeoff is accepting today’s market value and giving up any future upside.
Rent It and Hold
Holding gives you more time for appreciation, mortgage paydown, and potential rent growth. But you also continue covering any monthly shortfall and taking on repair, tenant, vacancy, and HOA risks.
Say you hold for another year with a $1,000 monthly shortfall. That’s $12,000 in additional cash you need to contribute.
If you eventually sell for the same price available today, you’ve spent that additional $12,000. Principal paydown and tax effects may offset part of it, while repairs or assessments could increase it.
The useful question is: How much better would the future sale need to be to justify the cost and risk of waiting?
Reduce the Price in Small Steps
Small price reductions can feel easier emotionally, but they can become expensive if they stretch the process out without attracting buyers.
If your goal is to sell, use recent comparable sales, showing activity, and buyer feedback to identify a competitive price. Then weigh any proposed reduction against the cost of another month on the market.
Six Questions to Ask Before You Decide
Before making a decision, get clear answers to these questions:
- What does this property actually cost me each month? Include the mortgage payment, HOA dues, taxes, insurance, maintenance, vacancy, and any utilities you cover. Avoid counting taxes and insurance twice if they’re already included in your mortgage payment.
- How long can I comfortably carry that cost? Think about what fits your finances without draining reserves or creating ongoing stress.
- What would I actually receive or need to bring to closing? Ask your agent for a seller net sheet using a realistic sale price, mortgage payoff, and estimated selling expenses.
- What would have to happen for holding to leave me better off? Consider appreciation, rent changes, principal paydown, expenses, and the length of time you plan to hold.
- Are there HOA issues that could change the numbers? Rising dues, deferred maintenance, litigation, or special assessments belong in the decision.
- What else could I do with my money and monthly cash flow? Eliminating a recurring shortfall could help rebuild your reserves or make room for another opportunity.
What If You Owe More Than the Property Is Worth?
If the sale proceeds won’t cover your mortgage payoff and selling expenses, you may need to bring cash to closing.
If that isn’t possible, contact your lender early to discuss your options. One possibility is a short sale, in which the lender agrees to accept less than the amount owed.
A short sale requires lender approval, can affect your credit, and may involve additional legal and tax considerations. Ask whether you could remain responsible for any unpaid balance before agreeing to terms.
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau explains how short sales work. Your lender, a real estate attorney, and your CPA can help you evaluate the consequences for your situation.
Include Taxes in the Calculation
The amount you bring to closing doesn’t determine your tax loss. Your purchase basis, improvements, depreciation, selling expenses, and how you used the property can all affect the calculation.
A loss on the sale of your primary residence generally isn’t deductible, as explained in IRS Publication 523.
Rental and investment properties receive different treatment. A loss may be deductible, but depreciation, prior personal use, and other tax rules can affect the result. IRS Publication 544 covers sales of business and investment property.
Have your CPA estimate the tax impact so you can compare selling and holding using numbers that reflect your situation.
How We Help Sellers Work Through the Decision
When my team talks with a seller whose property is losing money, we start with the information they need to make a decision:
- What comparable properties have actually sold for.
- How buyers are responding to the listing.
- What each additional month of ownership costs.
- What the seller would likely net at different sale prices.
- What would need to happen for holding to produce a better outcome.
Then we walk through the options without judgment.
You might decide that holding fits your finances and long-term goals. You might decide that paying to exit is worth the relief and improved monthly cash flow.
Either way, the decision should come from a clear comparison.
My Advice
Don’t let the word “loss” make the decision for you.
What you paid matters for your financial records and taxes. But today’s decision is about what happens next: the money you’ll contribute, the risks you’ll carry, and the opportunities you’ll keep or give up.
Sometimes holding is the right move. Sometimes selling at a loss prevents a larger financial setback.
Run the numbers before deciding which applies to you.
If you want a second set of eyes, book a call with me and The FI Team. We’ll review comparable sales, estimate your proceeds, and compare selling with holding so you can move forward with confidence.